CMF on Facebook CMF on Twitter CMF on YouTube RSS Get in Touch with CMF
menu resources

Abortion upper limit - We lost the vote but won the nation

summer 2008

From triple helix - summer 2008 - Abortion upper limit - We lost the vote but won the nation [p4]

PDF version
(Right click and choose 'save as...' to download a printable version of this article)

'Abortion fight “will go on after next election”, as MPs defy public opinion to keep 24-week limit', thundered the Daily Mail. 'Abortion debate: MPs are out of touch', concluded the Telegraph. 'Widespread disappointment at vote on abortion', observed the Times. These front page headlines, accompanied by high resolution ultrasound images of babies in the womb gave their judgment on Parliament's rejection of amendments to the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill[1] aimed at lowering the upper limit for abortion from 24 weeks to 12, 16, 20 or 22 weeks.

Inside pages carried testimonies of mothers whose children were 'born before the 24-week limit…who prove the law is wrong' and called 'contemptible' the action of whips who intimidated fellow MPs and blockaded the lobbies to ensure a vote for the status quo.

The campaigns run by 'Alive and Kicking'[2] and 'the 20 Weeks Campaign'[3] called for a modest change and resonated with the public mood. Testimonies, ultrasound images, stories of babies born after botched abortions, European comparisons, and survival statistics from top neonatal units had won the battle in the nation's living rooms, whilst tired warnings about returning to the days of back-street abortions and denials of advances in neonatal care had failed to impress.

However, voting fell heavily along party lines. The 332 MPs opposing 20 weeks included 35 Conservative, 248 Labour, 42 Liberal Democrat and 8 others. By contrast the 190 MPs supporting 20 weeks included 120 Conservative, 43 Labour, 13 Liberal Democrat and 14 others. This reflected the huge majority of pro-choice MPs in Parliament and the lead of the Prime Minister who, opposed to reducing the present 24 week limit, ordered a three line whip to ensure that Labour MPs, who largely favour abortion, attended.

We now know where virtually every MP stands on the matter. Alive and Kicking, representing twelve organisations including CMF, has produced an on-line database of MPs' views. But it may not be needed. If the composition of the next Parliament reflects voting in recent local elections and the Crewe and Nantwich by-election, then a 20 week vote will be won comfortably next time around.[4]

As Triple Helix went to press a backlash was in full swing, with a group of prochoice MPs led by Liberal Democrat Evan Harris attempting to liberalise the law through a variety of legislative, regulatory and other measures: abortion on demand up to 24 weeks; nurse-led abortions in polyclinics, cottage hospitals and GP surgeries; exclusion of pro-life doctors from counselling; and extension of the Abortion Act to Northern Ireland. By the time you read this you should know the outcome.

Article written by Peter Saunders

More from triple helix: summer 2008

  • A farcical footnote in history? - The HFE Bill
  • 'Diamond geezer' or ripe for retirement? - The NHS at 60
  • Abortion upper limit - We lost the vote but won the nation
  • A perfect storm - Micah's challenge about justice in global health
  • Advance decisions to refuse treatment - Ethical and practical concerns
  • The NHS at 60
  • Let's communicate about abortion
  • Conscience in the consultation
  • Christ in the Consultation
  • Is Christian faith good for health?
  • Ex-gays? - A Longitudinal Study of Religiously Mediated Change in Sexual Orientation (Book Review)
  • Making Sense of Medical Ethics - A Hands-on Guide (Book Review)
  • Elements of Medical Law (2nd edition) (Book Review)
  • Miracle at Tenwek (Book Review)
  • The Dawkins Delusion (Book Review)
  • God at work - Living every day with purpose (Book Review)
  • Setting Up Community Health Programmes (Book Review)
  • Does God Still Do Miracles? - An MD Examines (Book Review)
  • God's Undertaker - Has Science Buried God? (Book Review)
  • Future Perfect? - God, Medicine and Human Identity (Book Review)
  • Abortion - The Patient's and the Doctor's Dilemma (Book Review)
  • Eutychus
  • News from abroad
  • Cynicism in the surgery
  • Letters
  • Forsaken your first love?
  • Christian Medical Fellowship:
    uniting & equipping Christian doctors & nurses
    Contact Phone020 7234 9660
    Contact Address6 Marshalsea Road, London SE1 1HL
    © 2019 Christian Medical Fellowship. A company limited by guarantee.
    Registered in England no. 6949436. Registered Charity no. 1131658.
    Design: S2 Design & Advertising Ltd   
    Technical: ctrlcube