close
CMF on Facebook CMF on Twitter CMF on YouTube RSS Get in Touch with CMF
menu resources

a curious case

summer 2011

From triple helix - summer 2011 - a curious case [p18]

PDF version
(Right click and choose 'save as...' to download a printable version of this article)

The setting of this encounter is Lebanon, which was under the joint control of Rome and Syria; Jesus was able to stay with some Jews who lived there. He had gone away from Israel for a break but even so word got around, and this woman managed to push her way in.

Preachers use this story to talk about the 'great faith' of this woman. However, most hurriedly skate over Jesus ' extraordinary and apparently inexplicable behaviour, which at first (and even second) sight comes across as being dismissive, dishonest and insulting - uniquely so of the 23 recorded healings. So why did he treat this woman in such an out-of-character way?

Was he annoyed about having had his holiday disturbed? Was he grumpy after a bad night's sleep? Had some local kebabs disagreed with him? before seeking a better explanatin, let us acknowledge the difficulties:

Firstly, Jesus initially completely ignored her. But this contrasts starkly with the welcome he offered the Samaaritan woman even though this too was socially taboo. (1)

Secondly, he misled her by suggesting that Gentiles were not in his game plan. But this contrasts with what he already knew (2) and had proclaimed in his home synagogue - where he actually specified Sidon and Syria (3) - and it also contrasts with his ready welcome to the Gentile centurion. (4)

Thirdly, he effectively called her 'a dog', a common term that Jews used for Gentiles. But this contrasts with the attention, honour and compassion (remarkably anti-cultural) that Jesus displayed to women on every other occasion.

How do we explain this? It is important to realise that Jesus quickly saw that this woman was desperate and had no intention of taking 'No' for an answer. He certainly woul dnot have behaved this way towards a shy and deferential woman who might have run away at the first sign of being unwelcome.

It is often forgotten that this incident did not involve only Jesus and the woman - the disciples were there too. They had previously shown their prejudices against women (5) and the disabled, (6), and now their hostile views of Gentiles were clearly shown when they treid to get rid of this foreigner; their attitudes reflected their Jewish upbringing, culture and theology. By beavhing as he did, Jesus clearly and forcefully reflected back to them their own ungodly prejudices, exposing the way that they would have behaved (and as the woman must have anticipated). When Jesus does speak words of healing there is no reluctance but rather a celebration of her having sought him out. Indeed we can imagine that, having quickly assessed her pesonality, Jesus looked at her and spoke with her in a quizzical way, to encourage her to continue with her pleas; and it is very possible that he was laughing along with her by the end.

In our consultations it is very easy for our approach to be immediately coloured by prejudice. This might be related to reace, class, employment status, appearance; it might include alcoholics, refugees, drug addicts, smokers, homosexuals, the obese, unmarried mothers and so on. We need to search our hearts and minds to recognise and acknowledge our own biases, lest we (like the disciples) treat the patient as less than human.

Andrew Miller is a retired general physician who divides his time between medico-legal work, medical education at a Christian hospital in Egypt, and being a Street Pastor.

references

1. John 4: 7,27
2. Isaiah 42: 6
3. Luke 4: 16-27
4.  Mark 8: 5-13
5.  John 4: 27
6. John 9.2



Article written by Andrew Miller

More from triple helix: summer 2011

  • Faith matters in healthcare encounters
  • Missing midwives report
  • The BBC documentary 'Choosing to die'
  • Southern cross collapse
  • 23 week babies - the price of life
  • Welsh morning-after pill scheme
  • medical mission - changing the world together
  • stillbirths: tragedy and controversy
  • Learning from our suffering
  • Cross-cultural challenge
  • I never thought...
  • a curious case
  • The importance of prayer
  • you're teaching my child what?
  • AIDS action & Church communities confronting HIV & AIDS
  • Healthcare allocation & justice
  • On my way to heaven
  • A pathologist looks at healing
  • Better never to have been
  • 1-2-1 discipleship
  • Never let me go (DVD)
  • eutychus
  • conflict abounds
  • Christian Medical Fellowship:
    uniting & equipping Christian doctors & nurses
    Facebook
    Twitter
    YouTube
    Instgram
    Contact Phone020 7234 9660
    Contact Address6 Marshalsea Road, London SE1 1HL
    © 2019 Christian Medical Fellowship. A company limited by guarantee.
    Registered in England no. 6949436. Registered Charity no. 1131658.
    Design: S2 Design & Advertising Ltd   
    Technical: ctrlcube