From triple helix - spring 2018 - Medical abortion: concerns about taking a pill at home
(Right click and choose 'save as...' to download a printable version of this article)
Medical abortions now account for 62% of abortions in England and Wales, a significant increase from the 30% carried out in 2006. (1) In Scotland 83% of abortions are now medical. (2) President of the RCOG, Professor Lesley Regan, is leading calls for women to be able to take medical abortion pills 'in the comfort of their own homes', rather than abortion clinics or hospitals under medical supervision. Scotland now allows this (3) and pressure is building in Wales and Westminster to follow.
Medical abortions are usually used up to nine weeks gestation, but can also be after 13 weeks gestation. A woman is given an oral dose of mifepristone at a clinic/hospital then up to 48 hours later misoprostol is administered, orally or vaginally. This causes uterine cramping to expel the fetus. A follow-up visit is advised to ensure that the abortion is complete and there are no complications. It is misoprostol that can now be taken at home in Scotland.
It is claimed that taking the abortion pill at home is 'safe and sensible', it will fit better around work and childcare commitments and 'it is unacceptable for any woman to be made to risk miscarrying on her way home from a clinic.'
However medical abortions are far from 'safe' and easy and changing practice will be detrimental to women's physical and emotional health.
Removing medical supervision and support for a medical procedure is of concern for all women but particularly so for teenage girls or other vulnerable women. Taking such strong drugs is not to be taken lightly; in trials, almost all women using misoprostol for medical abortions experienced abdominal pain (considered severe by half) and a significant number experienced nausea, vomiting and diarrhoea. Medical abortions lead to more complications than surgical. A study of 42,600 first trimester abortions in Finland (where there is good registry data, unlike the UK) found that six weeks' postabortion complications after medical abortion were four times higher than surgical: 20% compared to 5.6%. (4) For abortions after 13 weeks gestation, the proportion of incomplete medical abortions needing subsequent surgical intervention varies widely between studies, from 2.5% in one study up to 53% in a UK multicentre study. (5) The RCOG also reports that women are more likely to need medical help for bleeding after medical abortion than after surgical, to report heavier bleeding than they expected, and for longer.
As yet there is little empirical research on the psychological fall out from abortions completed at home. Anecdotal evidence suggests it can be worse than after surgical abortions, perhaps because women see the baby, which they then have to flush away themselves, and the reminder of the abortion is always in the home, not in an anonymous clinic that they can leave behind.
1. Department of Health. Abortion Statistics, England and Wales:2016. Department of Health bit.ly/2G1BV5y
2. National Services Scotland. Termination of Pregnancy Statistics: Year Ending December 2016. National Services Scotland 30 May 2017. bit.ly/2pqUxFc
3. Calderwood C. Abortion-improvement to existing services-approval for misoprostol to be taken at home. Scottish Government 26 October 2017. bit.ly/2IFIIDL
4. Niinimäki M, Pouta A, Bloigu A, Gissler M, Hemminki E, Suhonen S, Heikinheimo O. Immediate complications after medical compared with surgical termination of pregnancy. National Center for Biotechnology Information October 2009. bit.ly/2DJcrIc
5. Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists. The Care of Women Requesting Induced Abortion: Evidence Based Clinical Guideline Number 7. RCOG November 2011. bit.ly/1JXcKh1