close
CMF on Facebook CMF on Twitter CMF on YouTube RSS Get in Touch with CMF
menu resources

film: I, Daniel Blake

May 2019

From nucleus - May 2019 - film: I, Daniel Blake

PDF version
(Right click and choose 'save as...' to download a printable version of this article)

I, Daniel Blake makes for uncomfortable watching. It follows the fictional story of Daniel Blake, who is told by his doctor he is unfit to return to work following a heart attack. But when he applies for medical disability benefit, he is refused. We follow Daniel as he, and young mother of two, Katie, struggle to negotiate the seemingly complex and robotic welfare system.

This is clearly a film with an agenda, so I should be upfront about mine straight from the off. As an actual doctor performing the medical assessments for the benefit which Daniel is refused, there were some parts of the film that left me furious, and others that left me heartbroken. I'll address the latter below before dealing with the former.

This film spotlights rising poverty in the UK, with real world food bank usage rising 13% in 2018 (1) and some 14 million people said to be living in poverty. (2) I applaud how the film challenges the damaging stereotypes of those claiming benefits as lazy, work-shy or 'scroungers'. This narrative is pushed by political groups and unfairly shames some of the most vulnerable in society. Both the main characters are like many, victims of poor circumstance and timing, and not at fault for their situation.

At every turn, Daniel is confronted by the bureaucracy of the system he is in, struggling both against his computer illiteracy in a digital age, and the mountain of red tape installed to try to discourage the dishonest, while protecting the deserving.

I agree with director Ken Loach, in his uncompromising portrayal of UK poverty, and about the flawed system we currently have. He does however, border on demonising those working in the system, and whilst I'm deeply saddened if this is experienced by even a minority, it is certainly not the norm.

The way Daniel's medical is conducted is frankly appalling and utterly unacceptable. However, I have never seen or experienced anything even close to this. The whole thing is a 'how-not-to' example, and while we only see a snapshot of his assessment, it is very clearly aiming to look incompetent. From a job centre employee being disciplined for showing basic human kindness, to the ever-looming government 'decision-maker' used like a Damoclean sword by staff, it would all be laughable, if it wasn't so insulting to those who try and guide some of the vulnerable through hardship and difficult times.

I, Daniel Blake is a film that dramatises events to create the saddest possible narrative with which to make its point. But it is also a stark reminder of the rising gap between rich and poor, and that social justice requires more than just paying our taxes. It's a reminder that we need to look at our greed as a society to ask why we feel more comfortable having 'subcontracted' such charity to the state. It's a reminder that we need to love our neighbour, and that as Christians our neighbour may not always live next door.

James Howitt is a doctor working in benefits assessment and CMF Associate Staff Worker


references

1. The Trussell Trust. End of Year Stats (2018-2019). bit.ly/2srmRXP

2. Social Metrics Commission. A new measure of poverty for the UK. September 2018. bit.ly/2xnjYvt



More from nucleus: May 2019

  • the editor is dead – long live the editor!
  • should Christians care about physical health?
  • a biblical approach to disability
  • does God heal miraculously today?
  • essentials:the life sandwich
  • time management
  • leadership: leadership and power
  • distinctives: diet options
  • treatment of Gender Dysphoria in children
  • be prepared : God will always be with you
  • a day in the life: assessing the sick
  • local groups: Leeds
  • counterparts: Romania
  • my trip to...Egypt
  • film: The Greatest Showman
  • film: I, Daniel Blake
  • book: Love Thy Body
  • book: 12 Ways your Phone is Changing You
  • news reviews
  • HERO + HERETIC 27: HELEN ROSEVEARE
  • Christian Medical Fellowship:
    uniting & equipping Christian doctors & nurses
    Facebook
    Twitter
    YouTube
    Instgram
    Contact Phone020 7234 9660
    Contact Address6 Marshalsea Road, London SE1 1HL
    © 2019 Christian Medical Fellowship. A company limited by guarantee.
    Registered in England no. 6949436. Registered Charity no. 1131658.
    Design: S2 Design & Advertising Ltd   
    Technical: ctrlcube